Tuesday, June 9, 2026Sports Chronicle
DailyClubGolf

Lexi Thompson's Controversial Penalty: How a Call Led to Playoff Loss and Golf Rule Change

KPMG Women s PGA, Golf Herren Championship Lexi Thompson of Florida lines up her putt on the 3rd green during the final round of the KPMG Women s PGA Championship at Sahalee Country Club on Sunday, June 23, 2024 in Sammamish, Washington. Sammamish Washington United States PUBLICATIONxNOTxINxFRA Copyright: xAmyxLemusx originalFilename:lemus-kpmgwome240623_npqn1.jpg

Lexi Thompson’s controversial penalty in 2017 led to an official change in the Rules of Golf. The American golfer was aiming to win the ANA Inspiration. After three rounds, she held the lead and was the favorite to win the tournament.

However, she suffered an unfortunate setback during the final round on Sunday, which ultimately caused her to miss out on the title. A television viewer had alerted officials to an error in Thompson’s ball placement during the third round of the event.

When she teed off for the final round on Sunday, LPGA Tour official Sue Witters approached her near the 13th hole and informed her that she was being given a four-stroke penalty. Thompson was stunned by the decision and said, “Is this a joke?”

On the 17th hole of the third round, she had placed the ball about an inch away from its original position. After being alerted by a fan via email, officials conducted a review and, the following day, assessed her a two-stroke penalty for incorrect ball placement and an additional two-stroke penalty for signing an incorrect scorecard.

The ruling was highly controversial and sparked widespread debate on social media. In its aftermath, the Rules of Golf were changed. A new decision, 34-3/10, was introduced to limit the use of video evidence in two ways.

First, if a rules violation is not visible to the naked eye and can only be detected through video footage, the player will not be penalized. Second, if tournament officials determine that a player made every reasonable effort to estimate or measure the line or position of the ball accurately, no penalty will be imposed.

Lexi Thompson’s infamous four-stroke penalty ultimately led to this rule change, though it also cost her the major title.

Lexi Thompson lost to Ryu So-yeon in a playoff at ANA Inspiration 2017

After receiving the harsh four-stroke penalty, Lexi Thompson, who otherwise might have won the title comfortably, finished the final round tied for the lead.

She then faced Ryu So-yeon in a playoff for the championship but eventually lost when Ryu made a birdie on the extra hole. Speaking after the event, Thompson said the situation was “unfortunate.”

“It’s unfortunate what happened,” Thompson said. “I did not mean that at all. I didn’t realize I did that.”

She received support from fans, fellow golfers, and celebrities on social media. Even the tournament winner, Ryu, commented on Thompson’s situation.

"It's a very unfortunate situation," Ryu said. "I didn't expect it. I thought I'm well behind, so all I wanted to do was play my game."

Although Thompson missed out on the major title in 2017, she had won the Chevron Championship in 2014, which remains the only major title of her career.

Read more at Club Golf!

Trending slideshow: Lexi Thompson’s 11 LPGA Tour Wins Revisited

Aditi Singh Lexi Thompson’s 11 LPGA Tour Wins Revisited
Lexi Thompson’s career is a story of power, resilience, and history-making moments. With 11 LPGA Tour victories, including a major championship, she has captivated fans around the world from the time she was a 16-year-old prodigy to her years as one of America’s most consistent stars. Each win tells its own story, sometimes dominant, sometimes gritty, but always unforgettable. Jorge Lemus/NurPhoto/Imago
At just sixteen years old, Lexi Thompson stunned the golf world in Alabama by becoming the youngest winner in LPGA Tour history at the time. Her powerful drives and confident putting separated her from the field, and fans recalled that every swing seemed to carry a statement: this wasn’t just a lucky week, this was a star being born. Romeo Guzman/Newscom World/Imago
Two years later, Lexi captured her second victory in Kuala Lumpur, showing she was no one-hit wonder. For fans, it was thrilling to see her game sharpen, her trademark length now paired with steady nerves; she handled both the climate and the international stage.. Charles Baus/Newscom World/Imago
Lexi ended her 2013 season in style by winning the Lorena Ochoa Invitational in Mexico, and she did it wire-to-wire. What made the win memorable for fans was the symbolism; here was a rising American star lifting a trophy in honour of one of the game’s greatest champions. Mexican crowds embraced her with warmth, and many said it felt like a passing of the torch moment. Duncan Williams/Cal Media/Imago
Her breakthrough moment came at Rancho Mirage when she lifted her first major trophy at just nineteen years old, outdueling Michelle Wie in a pressure-packed Sunday showdown. Lexi displayed composure well beyond her years, and then came the leap into Poppie’s Pond, golf’s most iconic victory celebration. Zuma Press Wire/Imago
In Michigan, Lexi’s fearless golf returned to centre stage as she fired a sizzling final-round 65 to win. For fans, what stood out was her confidence; she carried herself like she owned the course. The galleries loved her approachable demeanour, and her performance felt like a statement that Lexi was here to stay among the Tour’s elite. Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire/Imago
Later that season, she proved her game travelled anywhere by winning in South Korea. Competing against a deep international field, she played steady and fearless golf to secure another title. One reporter noted that she didn’t just win the event, she won the hearts of Korean golf fans. Brian Spurlock/Icon Sportswire/Imago
Shooting twenty-under-par, she left the rest of the field scrambling to keep up, where she simply overpowered the course. The atmosphere was electric, with Thai supporters chanting her name as she walked up the 18th fairway. It felt like a global showcase of just how far Lexi’s game could go. Lynn Pennington/ZUMA Press Wire/Imago
By 2017, Lexi was known as America’s most consistent contender, and her performance in Virginia only strengthened that reputation. She dismantled the Kingsmill course with clinical precision, hitting fairways and greens with almost machine-like accuracy. Icon Smi/Imago
Her second win that year came at the Brickyard Crossing Golf Course in Indianapolis, a venue famous for weaving around the Indy 500 racetrack. You can’t help but admire how she bounced back from tough moments earlier in the season to deliver under pressure. PGA
After a year full of ups and downs, she delivered in the biggest finale of the year, capturing her tenth career win at the LPGA’s season-ending championship. For Florida fans, it felt like a homecoming, celebrating one of their own with thunderous applause as she lifted the trophy. Nick Serrata/CSM/Imago
Her most recent victory came in New Jersey, where Lexi showed grit and firepower down the stretch. Birdies on the final holes sealed her eleventh career win, extending her streak of winning at least once every season for seven straight years. Her performance reminded everyone why Lexi, at her best, is so hard to beat. Roy K. Miller/Icon Sportswire/Imago

Written by

Ankita Yadav

Edited by

Sahil Prashar