2-time Super Bowl champion Eli Manning could not hide his surprise when Keegan Bradley unveiled a transformation that left him questioning everything.

Bradley plays for Boston Common Golf in the TGL league. On February 24, the team secured a playoff spot after a 9-2 win over New York Golf Club.

Keegan Bradley shaved his mustache before Boston Common Golf’s TGL match on February 24, calling it a “mojo” decision.

He first noticed the mustache and assumed it was part of the plan. After months of growth, though, Keegan Bradley showed up just hours later without it. Manning then made his stance clear.

“I’m not redoing this photo shoot. We put a lot of work and time into that,” he said about Bradley getting rid of the mustache.

Manning is an investor and limited partner in the New York Golf Club in TGL. He is part of the ownership group led by Steve Cohen, which also includes Derek Jeter, CC Sabathia, and Michael Strahan.

Yet, this is not the first time Eli Manning has traded banter with Keegan Bradley.

Eli Manning and Keegan Bradley’s Running Joke Extends Beyond TGL

In August 2025, during the FedEx St. Jude Championship, Eli Manning went undercover in different roles, including a FedEx courier and a tournament volunteer, as part of a prank on PGA Tour players.

At one point, wearing a bucket hat and sunglasses, he approached Keegan Bradley and a group of golfers. That is when he delivered the line, “I’m a FedEx courier at my real job. I always deliver, especially against the Patriots,” referencing Bradley’s loyalty to New England.

Bradley first looked confused and even called the disguised Manning a “freak.” 

However, once he realized who it was, he broke into laughter at the reveal of the two-time Super Bowl champion.

What do you think of Keegan Bradley's new look? Tell us in the comments.

Follow Club Golf for more updates.

Written by

Aditi Singh

Edited by

Sagnik Bagchi